The task says: “Comment on the message of the cartoon with respect to what makes good journalism in the 21st century.”
Tom has an opinion on almost everything. On this, right now, he has nothing. Five minutes pass. Then ten. He has read the cartoon four times and written one line.
Freezing on a comment task is common, and it is rarely about English. It usually comes from two wrong beliefs: that there is one right opinion the examiner wants, and that a good comment must cover every side perfectly.
What the task really asks
In the operator list for the Abitur from 2027, comment (on) means: state your own opinion, give reasons, and support it with evidence and examples. You can include counterarguments. You do not have to — Brandenburg’s guidance accepts a well-argued one-sided comment.
So there is no right opinion. There is only an opinion that is well supported, or one that is not.
Three ways to answer
Tom has three options, and most students have tried all of them.
Sit on the fence. Arguments for, arguments against, no verdict. It feels safe. It is not: a comment without a position misses the operator.
A list of reasons. One side, five quick points, no evidence. It has a position, but nothing proves it.
A clear position, well supported. Two or three reasons, each with an example or a detail from the material. Then one counterargument, answered. This is the strongest choice, and it is the one Tom picks.
What happened
His first sentence takes two minutes: The cartoon is right that speed now matters more than accuracy in many newsrooms — and readers pay the price. After that, the paragraphs come quickly: one reason per paragraph, each with a detail from the cartoon.
The result is not perfect. Tom spends too long on the counterargument and has to rush his conclusion. His position is clear and his reasons are supported, but the ending is thin. Next time he sets a time budget before he starts.
A plan you can copy
- First sentence: your position, in one sentence.
- Each paragraph: one reason, one piece of evidence, one sentence on why it matters.
- One counterargument: Some might argue that… However, …
- Conclusion: your position again, sharper than at the start. No new arguments.
A language tip for German speakers
In my opinion at the start of every paragraph gets repetitive. Vary it: I would argue that…, It seems clear that…, The strongest reason is…. And watch the false friend: actually means “in fact”, not aktuell. “Currently” is the word for aktuell.
Try it yourself
- Pick a cartoon or a statement from a past paper.
- Give yourself two minutes to write your position in one sentence.
- Write one counterargument and a one-sentence answer to it.
Then read the exact definition of comment and the other operators on Operatoren im Englisch-Abitur ab 2027, and practise with the free Argumentative Writing packs.
For the full structure with the PEE method and an outline template (in German), see Kommentar auf Englisch schreiben: Schritt-für-Schritt-Anleitung fürs Abitur.
